Opinions are of mine, and mine alone. Also, the numbers back me up, so I'm clearly right on all of this.
Offensive:
#1 - Alex Rodriguez - Sitting Ducks - 2007
.314 AVG
.422 OBP
183 Hits
54 Home Runs
156 RBI's
143 Runs
24 Stolen Bases
It's kinda crazy to think A-Rod was blackballed by our league at various points, but for a few seasons, he was the best player there was. The #1 overall pick ever in Wombat lived up to the hype in year one, putting up what I consider the greatest fantasy season in our history.
#2 - Albert Pujols - Crab Cakes - 2009
.327 AVG
.443 OBP
186 Hits
47 Home Runs
135 RBI's
124 Runs
16 Stolen Bases
Pujols was an absolute wrecking ball in 2009, leading the Crab Cakes to the first of back to back titles.
#3 - Miguel Cabrera - Megalomaniacs - 2013
.348 AVG
.442 OBP
193 Hits
44 Home Runs
137 RBI's
103 Runs
3 Stolen Bases
Arguably Miggy's best year was 2013, putting up one of the best single season averages seen in Wombat. He'd lead the Megas to another title in 2013.
#4 - Mike Trout - Kingslayers - 2012
.326 AVG
.399 OBP
182 Hits
30 Home Runs
83 RBI's
129 Runs
49 Stolen Bases
Trout burst onto the scene unlike any other player in Wombat history. His RBI numbers are "low" in 2012, but he more than made up for it with almost 50 swiped bags.
#5 - Joe Mauer - Ham Sandwiches - 2009
.365 AVG
.444 OBP
191 Hits
28 Home Runs
96 RBI's
94 Runs
4 Stolen Bases
I'm giving Mauer the edge on #5 here not because he's my boy*, but because in fantasy having a catcher hit like that is almost unfair. It was clearly a fluke year for Mauer, never touching those power numbers again, but for one year, he was one of the greatest ever.
*maybe
Apologies to:
2012 Miguel Cabrera
2007 Magglio Ordonez
2010 Josh Hamilton
2008 Albert Pujols
2007 Jimmy Rollins
2011 Matt Kemp
2018 Mookie Betts
Every Trout year
Many, many others