AI Analayzes AL

Wombatmetrics

Based on rosters alone, I asked Google's AI, Gemini, to pick the best team in the AWL. Here's what it said:

Gemini

Okay, let's break down these rosters and try to determine the best team based on projected 2025 performance, considering both established talent and potential. This is a complex task, and different people will value different things, but I'll aim for the team with the strongest overall balance and upside.

Here's my analysis of each team, leading to a pick:

Cold Notes

• Strengths: Solid catching, good potential in the infield (Witt, Kim, Massey), strong outfield with Alvarez and Garcia, decent pitching depth with Lopez and Baz coming back.

• Weaknesses: Question marks at 1B and 3B, some unproven SP.

• Overall: A decent team with some high-end talent, but also some holes.

Ham Sandwiches

• Strengths: Elite 3B (Ramirez), strong middle infield (Torres, Neto), potential in outfield (Langford, Cowser), good pitching at the top (Skubal, Olson).

• Weaknesses: Catcher is weak, 1B is a question mark, some unproven SP after the top two.

• Overall: Has some serious star power and promising young players, but lacks depth in some areas.

Kev Bombs

• Strengths: Elite middle infield (Semien, Correa), strong power potential in the outfield (Buxton, Arozarena, Soler), solid starting pitching (Castillo, Gilbert).

• Weaknesses: Catcher is weak, 1B is a question mark, some older/riskier players.

• Overall: High ceiling offensively, but relies on some players staying healthy and performing.

Kingslayers

• Strengths: Strong offensive core (Diaz, Lowe, Caminero, Bichette, Rooker), potential in young players (Dominguez, Greene, Kjerstad), high-end pitching (deGrom, Ryan, Miller).

• Weaknesses: Questions around deGrom's health, some volatility in the pitching staff.

• Overall: A team with a very high offensive ceiling and some top-tier pitching, but health is a major concern.

Megalomaniacs

• Strengths: Elite 1B (Guerrero), strong outfield (Rodriguez, Springer, Yoshida), decent pitching at the top (Fried, Lugo).

• Weaknesses: Inconsistent infield outside of Guerrero, relies on bounce-backs, pitching depth is questionable after the top.

• Overall: Has some star power but also significant question marks and potential for underperformance.

MoonSchatz

• Strengths: Elite young talent (Holliday, Westburg, Jung, Chisholm), strong offensive potential.

• Weaknesses: Catcher is weak, pitching is very questionable with a lot of unproven or risky arms.

• Overall: High upside based on young players, but the pitching is a major liability.

Pez Sox

• Strengths: Elite corner infield (Goldschmidt, Devers), strong middle infield (Seager, Crawford), potential in the outfield (Judge, Bellinger). Good starting pitching (Gausman, Bibee, Eflin).

• Weaknesses: Catcher is weak, some age concerns.

• Overall: A very strong and balanced team with a good mix of established stars and solid pitching.

Sittin' Ducks

• Strengths: Elite 2B (Altuve), strong outfield (Robert, Trout, Duran, Mullins), potential in young hitters (Henderson). Decent starting pitching at the top (Valdez, Eovaldi).

• Weaknesses: Catcher is weak, infield outside of Altuve is questionable, pitching depth is a concern.

• Overall: Has some very high-end offensive talent, but the supporting cast and pitching are weaker.

My Pick for the Best Team:

Based on the overall balance of offense, pitching, and relative lack of major weaknesses, I believe the Pez Sox are the best team in this league.

Reasons:

• Elite Corner Infield: Goldschmidt and Devers provide consistent high-end production.

• Strong Middle Infield: Seager is a premier shortstop, and Crawford is a solid contributor.

• High-Upside Outfield: Judge and Bellinger, if healthy and performing, provide significant offensive firepower.

• Solid Starting Pitching: Gausman, Bibee, and Eflin form a reliable top three.

• Relatively Few Obvious Weaknesses: While catcher isn't a strength, it's not a glaring hole compared to some other teams.

Other Teams Considered:

• Kingslayers: The offense is fantastic, and the top of the pitching staff is strong, but the health risk with deGrom makes them slightly less reliable.

• Ham Sandwiches: Has some top-tier talent, but the pitching depth and catcher situation are concerns.

• Sittin' Ducks: The top of the offense is great, but the infield and pitching are less impressive.

Ultimately, the Pez Sox appear to have the most complete and reliable roster heading into the season. They have a strong foundation of proven performers and a good pitching staff, giving them a high floor and a solid ceiling.